Pastor John and his wife, desperate to boost their church's popularity, shake things up by transforming their traditional Christmas pageant. The elderly choir director, Mary Margaret, is shocked and leads the choir in a boycott. With his job on the line, Pastor John takes drastic measures, disguising himself as an elderly man to connect with Mary and win over the choir. However, he soon discovers that the rift runs deeper than he anticipated, and he must learn to love the unlovable to save his church and family.

Altar Egos
A pastor and his wife shake up their church's traditional Christmas pageant, leaving their choir director stunned.