Ten years have passed since a devastating fire in Paris, leaving behind only a haunting mask. The love story of Christine Daae, a renowned soprano, and the Phantom, now an enduring passion, unfolds in Coney Island, NY. Christine, accompanied by her 10-year-old son Gustave and her husband Raoul, the Vicomte de Changy, travel to Coney Island for a performance at Hammerstein's, but find themselves singing for the enigmatic Mister Y instead. As Christine and Erik confront their past, old friendships are rekindled, and Christine's mysterious masked lover remains a constant presence, awaiting her next performance.

Love Never Dies
The story of the Phantom's enduring love for Christine Daae continues 10 years after a catastrophic fire in Paris, as he remains steadfast in his devotion to the soprano.