A young boy named Omri receives a wooden cupboard, antique keys, and a plastic Indian as birthday gifts. He locks the Indian in the cupboard, only to discover it comes to life the next day. The Indian, named Little Bear, claims to have learned English from settlers in 1761.

The Indian in the Cupboard
A mysterious birthday gift package arrives in Brooklyn, containing a wooden cabinet, vintage keys, and a plastic Native American figurine, courtesy of the boy's loved ones.