In the 19th century, a good woman named Matilda Dixon was wrongly accused of being a witch and burned alive. Before her death, she cursed the town and its descendants, vowing to return for each child's last tooth. Years later, a boy named Kyle accidentally saw the Tooth Fairy, which led to his mother's death.

Darkness Falls
A vengeful spirit, disguised as the Tooth Fairy, seeks revenge on a town that brutally slaughtered her 150 years ago, with a lone survivor from her initial attack now standing in her way.